2016Journal Article
Fast sorption measurements of VOCs on building materials: Part 2 – Comparison between FLEC and CLIMPAQ methods
Rizk, Malak; Verriele, Marie; Mendez, Maxence; Blond, Nadège; Dusanter, Sébastien; Schoemaecker, Coralie; Blondeau, Patrice; Calvé, Stéphane Le; Locoge, Nadine
Building and Environment
In: Building and Environment, vol. 99, pp. 239 - 251, 2016, ISSN: 0360-1323.
Read abstract
A new method was developed to measure on the field VOC sorption coefficients (ka; kd) on the surface of a material by coupling a Field and Laboratory Emission Cell (FLEC) to a Proton Transfer Reaction-Mass Spectrometer (PTR-MS) as presented in the first part of this study. In this second part, the method is compared to the classical method based on a CLIMPAQ chamber coupled to an on-line GC analyzer. Different models were used to determine the sorption parameters from experimental data taking into account the sink effect on empty chamber walls and the presence of a boundary-layer. Determined sorption equilibrium coefficients Ke (ka/kd) for a mixture of BTEX on a gypsum board was found to be in good agreement between both methods. However, the CLIMPAQ method seems to be less robust than the FLEC method in the determination of sorption coefficients since more than one couple of (ka; kd), showing the same ratio Ke can retrieve the same CLIMPAQ experimental data. Giving this result, the question arises about the reliability of the literature data determined using emission test chamber which could be one of the reasons behind the discrepancies found between experimental indoor concentrations and predicted ones using chamber derived parameters.
2016Journal Article
CFD analysis of SVOC mass transfer in different chambers
Mao, Yun-Feng; Li, Zhuo; He, Ya-Ling; Tao, Wen-Quan
International Journal of Heat and Mass Transfer
In: International Journal of Heat and Mass Transfer, vol. 99, pp. 613 - 621, 2016, ISSN: 0017-9310.
Read abstract
Semi-volatile organic compound (SVOC) in indoor environment is an important research topic because of their wide use and persistent effect on human health. SVOC chambers have been continually improved to study the mass transfer characteristics in indoor environment. CFD method is used in the present paper to study the effect on mass transfer, especially on steady time by velocity field from the comparison of SVOC mass transfer in two different SVOC chambers (A and B). The results indicate that the variance of air flow in small range strongly affects the steady concentration and has no obvious effect on steady time. Sorption ability itself has great impact on steady time. The great reduction of steady time in Chamber B is the combined effect of sorption and velocity field. The velocity field resulted from the special structure of Chamber B leads to a stronger convective mass transfer resistance, and hence causes a weaker effective sorption. Therefore, the less steady time in Chamber B is the result of weaker effective sorption besides a less sorption area of Chamber B than Chamber A.
2016Journal Article
A reference method for measuring emissions of SVOCs in small chambers
Wu, Yaoxing; Cox, Steven S; Xu, Ying; Liang, Yirui; Won, Doyun; Liu, Xiaoyu; Clausen, Per A; Rosell, Lars; Benning, Jennifer L; Zhang, Yinping; Little, John C
Building and Environment
In: Building and Environment, vol. 95, pp. 126 - 132, 2016, ISSN: 0360-1323.
Read abstract
Semi-volatile organic compounds (SVOCs) are indoor air pollutants that may have significant adverse effects on human health. Although emissions of volatile chemicals from building materials and consumer products are usually characterized in small chambers, few chamber studies have been conducted for SVOCs due to the challenges associated with analysis and the lack of validation procedures. There is an urgent need for a reliable and accurate chamber test method to verify these measurements. A reference method employing a specially-designed chamber has been developed and is undergoing extensive evaluation. A pilot inter-laboratory study (ILS) has been conducted with six laboratories performing chamber tests under identical conditions for di-2-ethylhexyl phthalate (DEHP). Results from this study showed inter-laboratory variations of 24% for DEHP emission rates, with closer agreement observed among intra-laboratory measurements for most of the participating laboratories. A mechanistic emission model fits well to the measured concentration profiles, demonstrating the feasibility of the proposed reference method to independently assess laboratory performance and validate SVOC emission tests.
2016Journal Article
The 40m3 Innovative experimental Room for INdoor Air studies (IRINA): Development and validations
Harb, P; Sivachandiran, L; Gaudion, V; Thevenet, F; Locoge, N
Chemical Engineering Journal
In: Chemical Engineering Journal, vol. 306, pp. 568 - 578, 2016, ISSN: 1385-8947.
Read abstract
Over the last 30years, several experimental chambers were developed and implemented for indoor air studies. Yet, they were not all representative of real indoor air conditions. Either they did not have sufficient volumes or they were hindered by difficulties to control experimental conditions and air exchange rates. In this context, a 40m3 Innovative experimental Room for Indoor Air studies (IRINA) has been developed and validated at Mines Douai (Atmospheric Sciences et Environmental Engineering department (SAGE)) to overcome these drawbacks and above all to perform reproducible indoor air studies avoiding any possible experimental biases. IRINA inner walls are covered with aluminum foils. The room is operated in a closed mode and is equipped with a VOC injection system that relies on the heated and pressurized injection of vaporized VOC. IRINA is also equipped with analytical instruments that allow the analysis of both gas (online and offline measurements) and particle phases. IRINA validation evidenced that: (i) the air exchange rate of the room is well controlled over an one year timespan; (ii) both gaseous and particulate background levels in IRINA remain lower than typical indoor air conditions; (iii) fast homogenization of injected VOC concentrations is reached in the room; (iv) adsorption phenomena on IRINA walls are limited; and (v) there is no VOC matrix impact regarding individual VOC decays. The modelling of VOC natural decay in IRINA based on the new INCA-Indoor model showed that the VOC removal in IRINA is mainly due to the air exchange rate.
2016Journal Article
Measurement of PCB emissions from building surfaces using a novel portable emission test cell
Lyng, Nadja Lynge; Gunnarsen, Lars; Andersen, Helle Vibeke; Kofoed-Sørensen, Vivi; Clausen, Per Axel
Building and Environment
In: Building and Environment, vol. 101, pp. 77 - 84, 2016, ISSN: 0360-1323.
Read abstract
Polychlorinated biphenyls (PCBs) were used in building materials like caulks and paints from 1930–1970s and in some cases that caused elevated PCB concentrations in the indoor air at levels considered harmful to occupant health. PCBs are semivolatile organic compounds and capable of spreading from the original source to adjacent materials, indoor air and via adsorption from the air to indoor surfaces, causing secondary contaminations. Remediation of buildings with unsatisfactory indoor air concentrations is a complex and difficult task due to the secondary contamination of building materials and there is a need to prioritise remediation measures on different materials. An inexpensive and portable emission test cell was developed to resemble indoor conditions in relation to the area specific ventilation rate. Emissions were measured using the test cell in the laboratory on freshly made PCB paint. Further, the chamber was used for determining emissions from PCB-containing building materials in the field as well as remediated walls. The measurements showed that sorption of PCBs to chamber walls was insignificant after 2–4 days of exposure to the source. Over a period of two weeks emission rates did not change from any of the tested surfaces, however in the laboratory experiment emission rates decreased over a longer period (48 days) and was most pronounced for the lower chlorinated PCBs.
2016Journal Article
Fast sorption measurements of volatile organic compounds on building materials: Part 1 – Methodology developed for field applications
Rizk, M; Verriele, M; Dusanter, S; Schoemaecker, C; calve, Le S; Locoge, N
Building and Environment
In: Building and Environment, vol. 99, pp. 200 - 209, 2016, ISSN: 0360-1323.
Read abstract
Several physicochemical processes occurring within buildings are key drivers of indoor concentrations of Volatile Organic Compounds VOCs. Many models and experimental studies have been proposed to predict VOCs concentration indoors given these processes. However, there is a lack of representative data in literature to present gas–surface interaction in order to validate mathematical models. This work is divided in two parts and aims to develop and validate a method to perform fast measurements of VOC sorption parameters on the field by coupling a Field and Laboratory Emission Cell (FLEC) to a Proton Transfer Reaction-Mass Spectrometer (PTR-MS). In the part 1 of the work, sorption coefficients of aromatic compounds on a gypsum board and vinyl flooring were investigated at ppb levels to test and evaluate the proposed methodology. Sorption coefficients in the range of 0.03–1.88 m h−1 for ka and 2.04–17.32 h−1 for kd were successfully measured within a (0.5–8 h) for the two materials. Robustness tests highlight that the determination of sorption coefficients does not depend on operating conditions. While sorption coefficients for the gypsum board were measured with a PTR-MS time resolution of 20 s, the vinyl flooring material required measurements at a higher time resolution of 2 s due to its lower sorption properties. Limits of applicability assessed for this method indicate that sets of sorption parameters (ka, kd) of (0.01 m h−1; 0.01 h−1) and (0.09 m h−1; 0.09 h−1) can be measured with an accuracy better than 10% at time resolutions of 2 and 20 s respectively.
2016Journal Article
Migration of DEHP and DINP into dust from PVC flooring products at different surface temperature
Jeon, Seunghwan; Kim, Ki-Tae; Choi, Kyungho
Science of The Total Environment
In: Science of The Total Environment, vol. 547, pp. 441 - 446, 2016, ISSN: 0048-9697.
Read abstract
Phthalates are important endocrine disrupting chemicals that have been linked to various adverse human health effects. Phthalates are ubiquitously present in indoor environment and could enter humans. Vinyl or PVC floorings have been recognized as one of important sources of phthalate release to indoor environment including house dust. In the present study, we estimated the migration of di(2-ethylhexyl)phthalate (DEHP) and di-isononyl phthalate (DINP) from the flooring materials into the dust under different heating conditions. For this purpose, a small chamber specifically designed for the present study and a Field and Laboratory Emission Cell (FLEC) were used, and four major types of PVC flooring samples including two UV curing paint coated, an uncoated residential, and a wax-coated commercial type were tested. Migration of DEHP was observed for an uncoated residential type and a wax-coated commercial type flooring. After 14days of incubation, the levels of DEHP in the dust sample was determined at room temperature on average (standard deviation) at 384±19 and 481±53μg/g, respectively. In contrast, migration of DINP was not observed. The migration of DEHP was strongly influenced by surface characteristics such as UV curing coating. In the residential flooring coated with UV curing paint, migration of DEHP was not observed at room temperature. But under the heated condition, the release of DEHP was observed in the dust in the FLEC. Migration of DEHP from flooring materials increased when the flooring was heated (50°C). In Korea, heated flooring system, or ‘ondol’, is very common mode of heating in residential setting, therefore the contribution of PVC flooring to the total indoor DEHP exposure among general population is expected to be greater especially during winter season when the floor is heated.
2016Journal Article
Early stage C-history method: Rapid and accurate determination of the key SVOC emission or sorption parameters of indoor materials
Xiong, Jianyin; Cao, Jianping; Zhang, Yinping
Building and Environment
In: Building and Environment, vol. 95, pp. 314 - 321, 2016, ISSN: 0360-1323.
Read abstract
The accurate and rapid determination of the emission parameters of semi-volatile organic compounds (SVOCs) from indoor materials is of great importance for estimating and controlling indoor exposure. By virtue of a simplified mass transfer model we derived, a new method called the early stage C-history method, has been developed to measure the key emission parameters: the gas phase SVOC concentration adjacent to the material surface (y0) and the convective mass transfer coefficient (hm). We validate this model using experimental data found in the literature. When compared with established methods, the new method has the following salient features: (1) rapid (the experimental time is reduced from several months to several days); (2) accurate (R2 in the range of 0.92–0.97). Further analysis shows that both features can be further improved if the test system has a smaller chamber wall/air partition coefficient. The new method is also extended to measure the key parameters of SVOCs from sorption materials. This method should prove useful for screening SVOC emission characteristics and for assessing exposure, as well as for chamber and test design.
2016Journal Article
Passive flux sampler measurements of emission rates of phthalates from poly(vinyl chloride) sheets
Noguchi, Miyuki; Yamasaki, Akihiro
Building and Environment
In: Building and Environment, vol. 100, pp. 197 - 202, 2016, ISSN: 0360-1323.
Read abstract
Emission rates of bis(2-ethylhexyl)phthalate (DEHP) from poly(vinyl chloride) (PVC) sheets containing DEHP as a plasticizer at various contents (0.16%–32.3%) were measured using the passive gas flux sampling method. The gas sampler was made of Pyrex glass and had a glass fiber filter inside. The sampler was placed on the surface of a PVC sheet for a given sampling period (up to 24 h), then the DEHP captured by the glass fiber filter was determined by gas chromatography-mass spectrometry. The sampling temperature was 50 °C. The surface concentration y0 (the DEHP concentration in the gas immediately adjacent to the surface of the PVC sheet) was determined from the experimental results and a transient DEHP emission model. The surface concentrations that were found agreed with values that have previously been published, most of which were determined in chamber emission experiments that require a longer test period than was used here. The method presented therefore allows the surface concentration y0, which is considered to be one of the most important parameters determining SVOC emissions from solids such as PVC sheets, to be determined quickly and simply. The experimentally determined surface concentrations and the DEHP contents of the PVC sheets that were used correlated well.
2016Journal Article
Characterizing the equilibrium relationship between DEHP in PVC flooring and air using a closed-chamber SPME method
Liu, Cong; Zhang, Yinping
Building and Environment
In: Building and Environment, vol. 95, pp. 283 - 290, 2016, ISSN: 0360-1323.
Read abstract
The di-(2-ethylhexyl) phthalate (DEHP) concentration in the air immediately adjacent to a polyvinyl chloride (PVC) flooring surface, y0 (μg/m3), has been identified as one of the critical parameters governing the emission process and consequent exposure. At room temperature and below, the relationship between y0 and the vapor pressure of pure DEHP (Psat) is still unclear. Few studies have been conducted to examine the influence of the mass fraction of DEHP in PVC on the relationship. In this study a new closed-chamber solid phase microextraction (SPME) method is developed to characterize ratio of y0 to Psat at 23 °C. This method avoids the artifact from wall-loss of sampling lines and of the thermal desorption system, in contrast to ventilated-chamber methods. Results show that at 23 °C y0 is significantly lower than the vapor pressure of pure DEHP. When the mass fraction of DEHP in PVC flooring increases from 13% to 23%, y0/Psat is increased by 7.2%, similar to what is reported in the literature. The sorption capacity of SPME stainless steel (SS) rods differs by up to 104%, although they are all made of SS. Based on error analysis, strategies are recommended to improve the precision and time efficiency. The method developed here should work for other SVOC-polymer systems.
2016Journal Article
Indoor air quality investigation of the school environment and estimated health risks: Two-season measurements in primary schools in Kozani, Greece
Kalimeri, Krystallia K; Saraga, Dikaia E; Lazaridis, Vasileios D; Legkas, Nikolaos A; Missia, Dafni A; Tolis, Evangelos I; Bartzis, John G
Atmospheric Pollution Research
In: Atmospheric Pollution Research, vol. 7, no. 6, pp. 1128 - 1142, 2016, ISSN: 1309-1042.
Read abstract
Two primary schools and one kindergarten were selected in the city of Kozani, Greece in order to investigate the school environment, the indoor air pollutants that children are exposed to and possible health risks at school. In each school three classrooms and one outdoor position were monitored from Monday to Friday, in both non-heating (26/09/2011–14/10/2011) and heating (23/01/2012–10/02/2012) period. Temperature, relative humidity and CO2, were continuously monitored. Formaldehyde, benzene, trichloroethylene, pinene, limonene, NO2 and O3 were measured with diffusive samplers. CO was monitored every day (30 min/day). Radon was measured for four weeks with short term radon detectors. PM2.5 was gravimetrically determined while PM2.5 and PM10 fractions were measured using the optical light scattering technique. Building material emission testing for VOCs was performed using the Field and Laboratory Emission Cell (FLEC). The ventilation rate for each classroom was calculated based on the CO2 measurements. Results indicated that indoor air concentrations of the measured pollutants were within accepted limits with indicative ranges 1.5–9.4 μg/m3 for benzene, 2.3–28.5 μg/m3 for formaldehyde, 4.6–43 μg/m3 for NO2 and 0.1–15.6 μg/m3 for O3. Emissions from building materials seem to have a significant contribution to the indoor air quality. Very low ventilation rates (0.1–3.7 L/s per person) were observed, indicating inadequate ventilation and possible indoor air quality problems requiring intervention measures. The estimated average lifetime cancer risks for benzene, formaldehyde and trichloroethylene were very low.
2016Journal Article
Influence of suspended particles on the emission of organophosphate flame retardant from insulation boards
Lazarov, Borislav; Swinnen, Rudi; Poelmans, David; Spruyt, Maarten; Goelen, Eddy; Covaci, Adrian; Stranger, Marianne
Environmental Science and Pollution Research
In: Environmental Science and Pollution Research, vol. 23, iss. 17, 2016, ISSN: 16147499.
Read abstract
The influence of the presence of the so-called seed particles on the emission rate of Tris (1-chloroisopropyl) phosphate (TCIPP) from polyisocyanurate (PIR) insulation boards was investigated in this study. Two Field and Laboratory Emission Test cells (FLEC) were placed on the surface of the same PIR board and respectively supplied with clean air (reference FLEC) and air containing laboratory-generated soot particles (test FLEC). The behavior of the area-specific emission rates (SERA) over a time period of 10 days was studied by measuring the total (gas + particles) concentrations of TCIPP at the exhaust of each FLEC. The estimated SERA of TCIPP from the PIR board at the quasi-static equilibrium were found to be 0.82 μg m−2 h−1 in the absence of seed particles, while the addition of soot particles led to SERA of 2.16 μg m−2 h−1. This indicates an increase of the SERA of TCIPP from the PIR board with a factor of 3 in the presence of soot particles. The TCIPP partition coefficient to soot particles at the quasi-static equilibrium was 0.022 ± 0.012 m3 μg−1. In the next step, the influence of real-life particles on TCIPP emission rates was investigated by supplying the test FLEC with air from a professional kitchen where mainly frying and baking activities took place. Similar to the reference FLEC outcomes, SERA was also found to increase in this real-life experiment over a time period of 20 days by a factor 3 in the presence of particles generated during cooking activities. The median value of estimated particle–gas coefficient for this test was 0.062 ± 0.037 m3 μg−1.
2016Journal Article
Data on comparison between FLEC and CLIMPAQ methods used for fast sorption measurements of VOCs on building materials
Rizk, Malak; Verriele, Marie; Mendez, Maxence; Blond, Nadège; Dusanter, Sébastien; Schoemaecker, Coralie; Blondeau, Patrice; Calvé, Stéphane Le; Locoge, Nadine
Data in Brief
In: Data in Brief, vol. 7, 2016, ISSN: 23523409.
Read abstract
A test emission chamber called CLIMPAQ has been coupled to a chromatography analyzer GC to measure volatile organic compounds (VOC) concentration during a sorption experiments (Fast sorption measurements of VOCs on building materials: Part 2 - Comparison between FLEC and CLIMPAQ methods, (Rizk et al., In press) [1]). The equations used to calculate the mass transfer coefficient and the thickness of the boundary layer developed on the surface of a material are presented. In addition, the experimental profiles obtained using the CLIMPAQ chamber is also presented in the presence and the absence of a building material. Finally, the impact of chamber size on the obtained concentration profile using different chambers is shown using 3 types of chambers having different volumes, 1 m3, 30 m3 and a micro chamber of 40 mL.
2016Journal Article
Characterization of organophosphorus flame retardants’ sorption on building materials and consumer products
Liu, Xiaoyu; Allen, Matthew R; Roache, Nancy F
Atmospheric Environment
In: Atmospheric Environment, vol. 140, pp. 333 - 341, 2016, ISSN: 1352-2310.
Read abstract
Better understanding the transport mechanisms of organophosphorus flame-retardants (OPFRs) in the residential environment is important to more accurately estimate their indoor exposure and develop risk management strategies that protect human health. This study describes an improved dual small chamber testing method to characterize the sorption of OPFRs on indoor building materials and consumer products. The OPFRs studied were tris(2-chloroethyl) phosphate (TCEP), tris(1-chloro-2-propyl) phosphate (TCIPP), and tris(1,3-dichloro-2-propyl) phosphate (TDCIPP). The test materials and products used as sinks include concrete, ceiling tile, vinyl flooring, carpet, latex painted gypsum wallboard, open cell polyurethane foam, mattress pad and liner, polyester clothing, cotton clothing, and uniform shirt. During the tests, the amount of OPFRs absorbed by the materials at different exposure times was determined simultaneously. OPFRs air concentrations at the inlet and inside the test chamber were monitored. The data were used to rank the sorption strength of the OPFRs on different materials. In general, building materials exhibited relatively stronger sorption strength than clothing textiles. The material-air partition and material phase diffusion coefficients were estimated by fitting a sink model to the sorption concentration data for twelve materials with three OPFRs. They are in the range of 2.72 × 105 to 3.99 × 108 (dimensionless) for the material-air partition coefficients and 1.13 × 10−14 to 5.83 × 10−9 (m2/h) for the material phase diffusion coefficients.
2016Journal Article
Laboratory study of PCB transport from primary sources to settled dust
Liu, Xiaoyu; Guo, Zhishi; Krebs, Kenneth A; Greenwell, Dale J; Roache, Nancy F; Stinson, Rayford A; Nardin, Joshua A; Pope, Robert H
Chemosphere
In: Chemosphere, vol. 149, pp. 62 - 69, 2016, ISSN: 0045-6535.
Read abstract
Dust is an important sink for indoor air pollutants, such as polychlorinated biphenyls (PCBs) that were used in building materials and products. In this study, two types of dust, house dust and Arizona Test Dust, were tested in a 30-m3 stainless steel chamber with two types of panels. The PCB-containing panels were aluminum sheets coated with a PCB-spiked primer or caulk. The PCB-free panels were coated with the same materials but without PCBs. The dust evenly spread on each panel was collected at different times to determine its PCB content. The data from the PCB panels were used to evaluate the PCB migration from the source to the dust through direct contact, and the data from the PCB-free panels were used to evaluate the sorption of PCBs through the dust/air partition. Settled dust can adsorb PCBs from air. The sorption concentration was dependent on the congener concentration in the air and favored less volatile congeners. When the house dust was in direct contact with the PCB-containing panel, PCBs migrated into the dust at a much faster rate than the PCB transfer rate due to the dust/air partition. The dust/source partition was not significantly affected by the congener's volatility. For a given congener, the ratio between its concentration in the dust and in the source was used to estimate the dust/source partition coefficient. The estimated values ranged from 0.04 to 0.16. These values are indicative of the sink strength of the tested house dust being in the middle or lower-middle range.